Which is the correct Tamil New Year, Thai-1 or Chithirai-1?

In his book , The History and Culture of Tamil People' ( Tamil), KK Pillai states that around 4–5 century BCE, Tamils already established trade relations with Greeks, Romans, Scythians and Arabs. There were rows of settlements in Madurai for the Greeks and Romans.

( you can get free access to this article: http://DX.doi.org/10.1080/0015587X.1917.9718974)

Is there textual evidence that support the claim that Tamils celebrated 14 January , Pongal day as their new year ?

‘The Life of Chuck’: Never Mind the Apocalypse, Watch Tom Hiddleston Dance! - Rolling Stone

The sangam literature Nedunalvadai vadai ( written somewhere around 2–3 century BCE), mentions that Mesham is the first month ( or first rasi ) from a point where the sun starts traversing to other rasi. This day is comparable with April in geregorian calendar. But even in Nedunalvadai nothing is mentioned about new year celebrations.

In 1917, another article was published titled “Bull - baiting, Bull - Racing , Bull - Fights , Folklore”, written by W.Crooks.

What's so great about the beginning of Chitrai month?

A Biologist Spotlights The World’s Most Aggressive Bird. Hint: It’s Flightless, It’s Not The Ostrich, And It’s Been Known To Kill People - Forbes

Though there is no direct textual evidence that 500 Tamil scholars gathered at Pachaiappan College , Madras in 1921 and declared Thai 1 as Tamil new year based on Thiruvalluvar calendar, however, there was no denial from those Tamil scholars who are contemporary to Maraimalai adikal.

Other Sangam (3r d BCE) and Bakti literature ( 5 th–9 th AD) also never uttered a word of new year celebrations.

The page 1 of the book says

Midea is recalling its U-shaped air conditioners because of potential mold growth - The Verge

However, the sanathani Hindus who believed the prurani stories that the calendar, astrology and new year originated from their gods, kept blowing the trumpet that Chitrai 1 is the new year.

In 1917, a book was written and published by Major C.H Buck who was the Punjab Commission then, on “Faiths, Fairs, And Festivals of India”. At page 82, he writes

To say there is assimilation of culture and acceptance towards knowledge from other areas of India or even from the Greeks the presence of the Prakrit names for the months and years in Tamil calendar is the evidence.

Kuorans can you write a sad story about kpop?

Another article was published in The Economic Weekly on May 24, 1952 written by Kathleen Gough, titled ‘The Social Structure of a Tanjore Village'. At page 584, it is written

“கடைகால் யாத்த மிடைமரச் சோலை, கொடுப்போர் ஓதையும் கொள்வோர் ஓதையும், நடுக்கு இன்றி நிலையிய நாள் அங்காடியில், சித்திரைச் சித்திரைத் திங்கள் சேர்ந்தன, வெற்றிவேல் மன்னரற்கு உற்றதை ஒழிக்க எனத்,தேவர் கோமான் ஏவலிற் போந்த காவற் பூதத்துக் கடையெழு பீடிகைப் புழுக்கலும், நோலையும், விழுக்கு உடை மடையும், பூவும், புகையும், பொங்கலும் சொரிந்து, துணஙகையர் குரவையர் அணஙகு எழுந்து ஆடிப், பெருநில மன்னன் இருநிலை அடஙகலும், பசியும், பிணியும், பகையும் நீங்கி, வசியும், வளனும் சுரக்க என வாழ்த்தி, மாதர் கோலத்து வலவையின் உரைக்கும், மூதிற் பெண்டிர் ஓதையின் பெயர”

The oldest Tamil grammar book, Tholkapiyam written some 3000 years ago did not provide illustrations about new year celebrations held by Tamils on a particular day.

Hello,hope y'all doin good, i came to Quora to share my strange story , a very weird one , a story when luck smiled at me ,maybe u will enjoy it , let's begin,have fun... A year ago ,I was a real porn addicted(btw I was 18) ,but never had sex before, I don't have a gf I didn't try to find one even ,always thinking to go to find a sex worker but then I just don't , everyday watching different bodies getting fucked and everyday enjoying. One day, I was watching porn, a big ass lady with big boobs ,just after seeing her the image of my female cousin poped in my mind, (let's introduce her : she's 35 years old , very big ass , nice boobs ,not very big but nice,always wearing tight clothes , she's divorced ) and I thought of me fucking her ,I never had sexual desires for her but now I do days went by and when I met her I was so horny ,I couldn't stay with the family cz my penis was clearly erected , I realized this is my first time I get horny for one of my family ,it not illegal in my country.well to make a long story short( if u want details just text me I will tell u 😊),I decided to give her signs that I want to fuck her,finally I decided to have sex and with my cousin , I thought it is the best beggining for me, i started touching her when I came across her in a narrow place , make her feel my hard cock when we hug , I thought it will hard and I will be ashamed but no , I felt nothing and she said nothing , probably she thought it was by mistake,anyways, I decided then to talk with her about sex, waited for her to be alone in a room and talk with her, I confessed everything about me watching porn and addicted..etc,she said it's normal and u are growing up and u must have sex,well at that time I was like whaaat????? Well I didn't control myself and asked her for sex ( horny like I Ve never been before) she said that she will think Abt it ,2 weeka went by then she called me ,telling that she reserved a room in a hotel and we meet tonight ,we met,and bruuhh, sex is great , I mean, I had to find a pirstitue ,what I was waiting for to have such a feeling ????, I will never forget that night, I started kissing her she was kissing hard ,she misses sex so bad , she sucked my dick and swallowed my semen ,I felt I'm in a dream , then when fucked ,her ass was very big and the anus was open ,didn't struggle to get my hard cock inside it , she was obviously missing sex , she was shouting ,fuck me yh fuck me , I go fast after every word until I cum , we did that 3 times , then we went to her pussy , using condoms I fucked her so hard the moans were higher , everything was perfect ,in the end I asked her to lick her body , licked pussy ,ass, boobs,then she sucked my cock until we sleeped ,all I know that she was dirty ,well before even having sex with her I knew she is an open minded woman , and a woman that looks that she donesnt know anything , but she knows everything, but never expected having sex with her ,well she was horny and that helped...but no one of us regretted that sex ever.. We still have sex from time to time ,and I started having sex with sex workers , joining threesomes..etc If u want pics of her text me.

The 7–9 th century (AD) bakthi literature in Tamil also did not say a word about April 14 ( Chtrai -1) New Year celebrations, not acknowleding that it was an important time for Tamil people. However, the Alwar pasurams and Thevaram mentions about Margazhi fasting, Thiruvonam and Thaipusam. Where is Chitrai mentioned in those literature?

In fact we have textual evidence for the claim that Maraimalai adikal' s students, professor Ki. A, Pe,Visvanathan, endorsed Thai 1 as Tamil new year and it was refuted by Maraimalai adikal.

No sane Tamil man will celebrate a terribly hot summer day as the begining his New Year - when the ensuing days should bring fortune and luck. Of course during summer, some trees bloom with flowed and fruits like mango is obtained in abundance. This does not mean it is the day of spring.

Can people who have never met you tell if you are a covert narcissist?

For the opponents Thai -1, what's your reply for this? Is prof Mukerji a supporter of Dravidian idealogy?

History provides evidence that the homeland of the Tamil came under the influence foreigners ( Greeks and Romans through trade relations) and people from the north, the Jains who used Prakrit and during this time there was voluntary assimilation of cultures and knowledge of astronomy. The Tamils could have pick up and adjusted their their calendar accordingly.

This is the month a festival that the Tamils call it as summer festival ( KOdai Thiruvila) celebrated as this month is extremely hot all over Tamil nadu, water is scarce, not agriculture produce, and people rejoice ‘manjal neerattu' by throwing water after temple festivals.

3 Black Holes Caught Eating Massive Stars in NASA Data - NASA Science (.gov)

As for the Tamils, Thai -1 which falls on the 12th–14th of January invariably , based on solar calendar, is the day they celebrate in grand manner the Pongal Festival- relatable to New Year celebration. The village folks in TN welcome Thai- 1 as the day and month fully revered because this day would be the starting day for the many good fortunes that will follow here after.

Now let us see and inspect our own literatre.

Tell me where is it mentioned about Tamil new year in Silapathikaram? Is Tamil new year currently celebrated on a full moon day in Chitrai?

Protein bars may not have the health benefits that you think, study finds - AOL.com

However, a 12th century AD scholar Natchinarkiniyar, after studying Tholkapiyam, exposed that during Tholkappiyam era, Avani 1 ( month of Simmam )was the beginning of the year.

Why sudden romance for Thai 1 New Year from the Dravidian party?

Thai - 1 is Tamil new year. Why ? There is textual evidence even way before the Dravidian politics introduced Thai 1 as the begining of Tamil New Year.

Adventure Calls from the Lost City of Un’Goro, Hearthstone’s Next Expansion - Blizzard Entertainment

Lately, the Tamil Chintanaiyalar Peravai which claims that everything that are made by man has its origin in Tamil civilization includes calendar and festivals. This Peravai labels the brahmins as Jews. According to this Peravai the knowledge of the Tamils were stolen by this brahmin Jews and later translated into Sanskrit. Believe it! Otherwise you are not a Tamil.

“ Pongal ( a Tamil word meaning ‘ boiling' ) takes place at this time on the 1st day of Tamil Year. It is in honour of the birth of Mithras ( the Sun) and the renewal of the solar year. There is much rejoicing because the unlucky month of Poh is over, and the because each day of the ensuing month is regarded lucky”.

“ In dealing with with a custom like this ( about Jallikattu) the date of the performance is of vital importance. In this case it is practiced on the Mattu- Pongal day, the day after the Pongal festival which held on the Tamil New Year's Day , approximately on 12 th January”.

Why do older people have a hard time using technology?

So in 1950’s, the Pongal day, in January was considered the start of the Tamil New Year.Why there is sudden surgence and romance for Chitrai 1 as Tamil new year?

In 1609, a catholic paderi, Nopili had stayed in Madurai Tamil nadu, and recorded his observations on the culture and life styles of the Tamils. Hence, you can download free from the internet archives the book.

I don't know why these Chitrai 1 scholars keep quoting Silapathikaram for evidence of Chitrai new year's antiquity. Sorry to say, don't over interpret.

Where did Noah build the Ark? Was it in a desert or near water?

Why these Chitrai 1 new year supporters keep relating summer festival to spring festival ,only God knows!

Yes, there is.

In 1917, if the British writer can acknowledge that Pongal day on Thai - 1 is the beginning of Tamil year (the New Year), then what makes the Tamil people in 2023 to reject it, just because you hate Dravidian movement, isn’t it ? Anyway, who told the British researchers to treat Pongal as Tamil new year. Don't tell me they made wild assumptions. If they did, then why Prof Mukerji also writes 12–14 January, the Makara Sankranthi, is new year?

Meta buys a nuclear power plant (more or less) - TechCrunch

I have already established that way before the Dravidian politics showed love for Thai 1, the Tamil people in the villages have already given the status of Tamil new year to the Pongal festival.

God bless Tamils.

The verses 61–75 in Silapathikaram, an epic in Tamil, speak about Chitrai star, Chitrai month and the full moon day. On this day, the women who belonged to the warrior clan, offered pongal( cooked rice) , ellurundai, flower, and sambrani pugai and worshiped a deity (பூதம்) and danced for the wellbeing of their their king.

Blood test detects multiple cancer types through cell-free DNA - Medical Xpress

The Silapathikaram, according to some quorans, is another source of evidence for Chitrai -1 as Tamil new year. Silathikaram did mention at many places about Tamil nadu, Tamil but never a word about Tamil New Year.

Is it true that Maraimalai adikal, the Pure Tamil Movement initiator, announced Thai 1 as the begining of Tamil new year in 1921?

In other words, what we understand is that the Tamils never took new year celebration seriously some 3000 thousand years ago. However, they had a calendrical system which was solar.

How can I stop overthinking and take action more quickly?

So, Thai 1 is our new year from those olden days, Chirai 1 was a later invention by astrologers and puranic followers .

In 1918, prof A.C. Mukerji, from Muir Central College, Allahabath writes a book titled Hindu Fasts and Feasts. You can download free from internet archives.

The constellations , the group of stars is the called ‘orai' in Tamil, in Greek it is called ‘orion’ . Tamil traders had travelled from Tamil nadu to Greece and vise versa. So there was exchange of ideas of astronomy aside selling of goods.

Do you think that drug addiction is a symptom of larger societal ills? What is it about our culture that leaves so many feeling like they're inadequate, trying any ill to find a cure?

Page 147 of the article says

“ Other events and festivals unites the village as a whole. Chief of these are Pongal, the annual festival for the harvest of the second crop in January, and the day of the first ceremonial ploughing, at the start of the Tamil New Year.”

‘Thai Piranthal Vazhi Pirakkum' is a famous phrase among Tamils denoting the positive changes will happen here after.

“ Makara Sankranthi is thus a kind of New Year's festival, marking the the sun's attainment of the most southern point in the ecliptic, and the commencement of the northernly or what in the religious phraseology is called ‘Uttarayana'. Astronomically , it is New Year's day indeed, ……for Makara Sankranthi invariably falls between the 12th and 14th of January each year”

Spring is the season which marks the end of winter and beginning of blooming of flowers. While the Sun is right above our head during April in Tamil nadu, its pretty hot and the summer have killed some individuals, the northern hemisphere enjoys relatively cooler season where flowers bloom everywhere. They can call it aspring.